Ohio vs. Michigan Beer Battle Round 5 – White Rajah vs. Two Hearted Ale

Ohio_Mich_Round5

In round 4 the dark roasted malts were center stage.  In round 5 we go to the opposite extreme with two beers where the juicy American hops dominate, completely overshadowing the malts: The Brew Kettle’s White Rajah vs. Bell’s Two Hearted Ale.   

White Rajah by The Brew Kettle (Strongsville, OH) – The Brew Kettle is a medium sized brewery located in Strongsville, which is a suburb of Cleveland.  You can get quite a few Brew Kettle beers in Columbus, but among those that I’ve tried one stands above the rest, White Rajah.  The description on the label sums this beer up pretty well “A West Coast style IPA full of citrus-like and tropical fruit-like hop flavor and aroma with an assertive yet smooth bitter finish …. malt, take a back seat please”.  If you scroll down in the taste test section of this site you can find the IPA challenge we had back in October, where White Rajah beat out nine other beers to win the title of the best IPA in the world (that you can buy in Columbus). That’s why I chose this beer to represent Ohio over other renowned Ohio-brewed IPAs like Headhunter IPA and Columbus IPA. White Rajah clocks in at 6.8% abv and 70 IBUs.

Two Hearted Ale by Bell’s (Kalamazoo, MI) – This is our second and last Michigan entry from Bell’s, the largest brewery in Michigan and 7th largest in the US.  I suspect most readers of this site will need no introduction to this beer.  Two Hearted Ale is an iconic American IPA, and long-time go to beer among Midwest hopheads. Somewhat unusually only one variety of hops, Centennial, is used in Two Hearted Ale.  The aroma and taste of this beer are a testament to the versatility of the Centennial hop.  I find there are variations from batch to batch in the quality of Two Hearted Ale, but this beer was exceedingly fresh (only bottled two weeks ago) and representative of Two Hearted Ale at its best. It tips the scales at 7.0% abv and 55 IBUs.

Picking a Winner

As with all of the other rounds in this contest I give you two perspectives on the winner.  We threw a party and invited a dozen ordinary folks (beer drinkers, but definitely not beer geeks) and had everyone choose their favorite of the two in a blind taste test. These results are captured in a short video shot live at the beer tasting party and found at the bottom of this post.  I call this the People’s Pick. I also tasted the beers side by side and offer my thoughts and pick for the best beer.  I call this Pat’s Pick.  Depending on your affinity for beer you can decide which opinion best represents your tastes.  Better yet go out and pick up each beer, try it for yourself, and leave a comment here to register your own vote for the winner.

My Review

White Rajah is a hazy, translucent beer that has a color I liken to liquid gold.  It pours with about 1 finger of white head.  Although the amount of head is pretty modest, if you swirl the beer around the glass it leaves behind a persistent white lacing on the walls of the glass.  The smell is hoptastic, over the top tropical citrus fruits, its aroma is as fruity as any IPA I’ve encountered.   Finally coming to the taste, the citrus fruits are still front and center, but they give way to a slightly piney, lingering bitterness on the finish.  This beer is a showcase for the hops, with no pretense of balancing them with the malts.  The mouthfeel is kind of sticky as you tend to get with IPAs, although interestingly as it warms the mouthfeel actually gets quite creamy.

The Two Hearted Ale pours a clear golden amber color with 2 fingers creamy white head.  As with the White Rajah, citrus fruits are also prominent in the nose, but not quite to the same extent.  The hops impart a nice fruity (oranges, grapefruits) taste on top of a slightly sweet malt base.  It’s a nicely balanced beer, for an IPA, with enough bitterness to keep the finish dry, but not so much bitterness to cause face contortions. It’s a classic example of the West Coast IPA style.

Pat’s Pick

Both beers lean heavily toward the tropical/citrus fruit hop profile, as opposed to the piney, resinous character that you get with some IPAs.  Neither is excessively bitter, so if you like you’re IPAs fruity and flavorful with restrained bitterness you would be in good hands with both beers. I’m drinking a Two Hearted Ale as I write this review and my brain is telling me this is a delicious beer.  I’ve been a little disappointed the last few times I’ve tried Two Hearted, but this batch has restored my faith.  However, White Rajah takes the IPA style to another level.  Comparing the two is like comparing 1963 Bob Dylan (Two Hearted) to 1966 Bob Dylan (White Rajah), the Yardbirds (Two Hearted) to Led Zepplin (White Rajah), or the Dubliners (Two Hearted) to the Pogues (White Rajah).  Some people prefer the classic and find the amped up version less appealing, and I can respect that opinion. If that’s you I would point you to the Two Hearted Ale, but I’ll take the supercharged version, so my vote goes to the White Rajah.  On a 1-10 scale I give Two Hearted Ale a 7.5 and White Rajah a 9.

People’s Pick

See the video below for the people’s pick.  Here I’m joined by the Bitter Bitch, an IPA-loving, dedicated follower of the site.  BB and I are in complete agreement on the awe-inspiring power of the White Rajah, but the alpha acid averse crowd throws a spanner into the works.  Sticking with the Bob Dylan theme I can sum up my feelings on the voting in this round by quoting from his classic 1976 song “Hurricane”

To be in the palm of some fool’s hand
To see a beer so obviously framed
Couldn’t help but make me feel ashamed                                                                                       To live in a land
Where the White Rajah is defamed

Updated Standings

Pat’s Picks:  Michigan = 3 vs. Ohio = 2

People’s Picks: Michigan = 3 vs. Ohio = 2

Next Round

Round 6 – Winter Warmers: Fathead’s Holly Jolly vs. Dark Horse’s 4-Elf

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: